We provide hints and tips to help you get started with the basic program RFEM.
FAQ 003429 | There are two different add-on modules for a response spectrum analysis in RF‑/DYNAM Pro. What can be the reasons for the different results of both add-on modules?
Video
First Steps with RFEM
Question
There are two different add-on modules for a response spectrum analysis in RF‑/DYNAM Pro. What can be the reasons for the different results of both add-on modules?Answer
The differences between the two modules are explained in this FAQ.
In the case of the same settings, there should also be the same results calculated in both add-on modules. However, this does not apply to the existing nonlinearities. The reason is that there are no nonlinearities considered in the RF‑/DYNAM Pro add-on module. If displaying the results in the Forced Vibrations add-on module, all nonlinearities are thus ignored. In contrast, the equivalent loads are calculated on a linear structural system, but the exported load cases are then calculated on a real structure in RFEM and RSTAB, that is, with all nonlinearities. This may lead to inconsistent results.
If you deactivate the nonlinearities for the exported load cases, you should obtain the same results.
The way of considering nonlinearities in the response spectrum analysis is described on the basis of tension members in this FAQ.
Keywords
Dlubal FAQ Response spectrum Dynamic analysis Difference Result Nonlinearity Equivalent load Frequently Asked Question FAQ about Dlubal Question and Answer about Dlubal
Links
Write Comment...
Write Comment...
Contact us
Do you have any questions about our products or need advice on selecting the products needed for your projects?
Contact us via our free e-mail, chat, or forum support or find various suggested solutions and useful tips on our FAQ page.
New
Deactivation of Nonlinear Effects
If nonlinear effects are used in the model, it is possible to deactivate them in the global calculation parameters.
![Window '1.1 General Data' for Serviceability Limit State with Settings for Nonlinear Calculation According to [2]](/-/media/Images/website/img/000001-010000/009301-009400/009376.png?la=en-US&mlid=149164433F8D4E0D89705EF3B002E4A8&hash=A7B507AEAEECF2AA3900D4C7A837EC8C5A08ADFB)
Considering the Stiffness of Gas Solids in Nonlinear Time History Analysis
The stiffness of gas given by the ideal gas law pV = nRT can be considered in the nonlinear dynamic analysis.
The calculation of gas is available for accelerograms and time diagrams for both the explicit analysis and the nonlinear implicit Newmark analysis. To determine the gas behaviour correctly, at least two FE layers for gas solids should be defined.
- There are two different add-on modules for a response spectrum analysis in RF‑/DYNAM Pro. What can be the reasons for the different results of both add-on modules?
- After calculating the add -on module RF-/DYNAM Pro - Equivalent Loads, the size of my file has increased significantly. The performance has deteriorated enormously. What could be the reason for this?
- Can I simulate the cracked state of a concrete cross -section for a bending beam with the "Isotropic Nonlinear Elastic 1D" material model?
- I would like to calculate and design "temporary structures." What do I need for this?
- Which programs can I use to calculate and design power plants?
- When defining my material, I get Warning No. 1136 and cannot continue working. How can I prevent this warning?
- Why do I get such a small amount of reinforcement for the upstand beam? The amount of reinforcement for the downstand beams is significantly larger.
- I noticed deviations from the map of DIN EN 1998‑1 or DIN 4149 in the online service "<a href="https://www.dlubal.com/en-US/solutions/online-services/snow-load-wind-speed-and-seismic-load-maps" target="_blank">Geo-Zone Tool: Snow, Wind, and Seismic Zone Maps</a>." Can you tell me which map is current and thus governing?
- How can I display the vertical deformation of a column in state II? I cannot find this setting for the serviceability limit state design.
- How do you distinguish between the response spectra with equivalent loads and the response spectra without equivalent loads in RFEM and RSTAB?
