Impact Load of Passenger Car on Carport

Technical Article on the Topic Structural Analysis Using Dlubal Software

  • Knowledge Base

Technical Article

The fundamental requirements of a structural system are (according to the basis of structural design) sufficient ultimate limit state, serviceability, and resistance. Structures must be designed in such a way that no damage occurs due to events such as the impact of a vehicle.

Load Combinations

In [1] Chapter 3.2(2)P, an impact is defined as an accidental design situation. Thus, Equation 6.11b applies to the combination of actions. The choice between the frequent value Ψ1,1 ⋅ Qk 1 and the quasi-permanent variable Ψ2,1 ⋅ Qk 1 depends on the governing accidental design situation. In [2] NDP to A.1.3.2, for example, in the case of a vehicle crash, it is specified that application of the quasi-permanent value Ψ2,1 ⋅ Qk,1 is allowed. Hence, snow loads and wind loads for locations in CEN member states with a height less than 1,000 m above sea level do not have to be considered in case of a vehicle impact, because their combination coefficients Ψ2,1 are usually defined as 0.0.

Defining Accidental Action

Now, we have to define the type and size of the impact. Part 1‑1 of the Eurocode 1 [3] in Chapter 1.1(6) refers to Part 1‑7 [4] where accidental actions are explained. Two methods are recommended in Chapter 4.2(1):

  • Determination of impact loads with a dynamic analysis
  • Definition of impact loads as equivalent static force

For information on the dynamic impact design, see Appendix C. This annex distinguishes between a "hard impact," where the energy is mainly dissipated by the impacting body, and a "soft impact," where the structure is designed to deform in order to absorb the impact energy. According to Annex C.2.1(1), calculating with an equivalent static force for a "hard impact" is allowed. In the event of a car crashing into a carport, a hard impact is assumed and the content of this article refers to the determination of the equivalent static force.

Image 01 - Car Crashing into Carport

In [4], Table 4.1, an equivalent static force Fdx in the direction of normal travel of 50 kN is proposed for passenger cars in parking garages. Transverse to the direction of travel, this results in the force Fdy of 25 kN. Due to the size of the load, it will probably be possible only very rarely to realize economical dimensioning of the column cross-sections of a carport. It should also be mentioned that collisions on lightweight structures are excluded in Chapter 4.1(1), thus Table 4.1 is not valid and reference is made to the National Annex. The installation of an impact protection that absorbs the impact in front of the column in order to carry out an economical design of the columns is not likely to be an option. The National Annex of Germany [5] describes a statically equivalent impact force of 10 kN for both directions for passenger cars ≤ 30 kN in Table NA.2‑4.1 for single and double garages as well as carports.

If the National Annex of a country does not provide further information, it is worth taking a look at [3], Annex B. In Equation B.1, the horizontal equivalent load for a fall protection is described. This results in:

Formula 1

F = m · v22 · δc + δb

According to Annex B(3) in [3], the following assumptions are selected:

m = 1,500 kg
δc + δb = 100 mm
v = 1.39 m/s

The impact velocity v deviating from B(3) is assumed with 5 km/h according to [4], Table C.1 for parking garages, which corresponds to 1.39 m/s. This results in an equivalent load of:

Formula 2

F = 1,500 kg · (1.39 ms)22 · 100 mm = 14.5 kN

Position of Accidental Action

According to [4], 4.3.1(3), applying the impact force of passenger cars at a height of 50 cm above the top edge of the road is allowed. In [3], Annex B, 37.5 cm are specified for passenger cars with a maximum vehicle mass of 2,500 kg. Since the height of a passenger car's bumpers is not standardized in most countries, the engineer has to decide at which height the equivalent load will be applied. The German Annex [5] recommends a height of 50 cm for passenger cars.

Complete Failure of Structural Components as Option

There is also the option to analyze the effects of complete failure of the affected structural component on the entire structure (Image 02). Depending on how the component is fixed, such an analysis can be useful.

Image 02 - Complete Failure of Column After Impact of Car

Designing Carport Column for "Impact" Load Case in RFEM/RSTAB

For the carport shown in Image 01, the impact of a passenger car on the central column will be simulated. The design will be performed according to the German Annex in this example.

For this purpose, a new load case has to be created first where the static equivalent load is defined. If the automatic load combination is used, the "Accidental" action class should be assigned to this load case.

Image 03 - New Load Case with "Accidental" Action Category

Afterwards, a new combination expression is created with the accidental design situation according to [2], Equation 6.11e.

Image 04 - New Combination Expression with Corresponding Design Situation

In this example, the distance of the equivalent load from the member start of 37.5 cm is selected, because the fastener (in this case, the height of the column footing) is not taken into account in the structural analysis.

Image 05 - Size and Position of Equivalent Force

The timber structure is designed with the RF‑/TIMBER Pro add-on module. The corresponding model files for RFEM and RSTAB are available at "Downloads" at the end of this article. In TIMBER Pro Case 2, the accidental design is carried out by selecting the corresponding load combination. Since the snow load and wind load do not have to be combined with the impact in this case, only the self-weight and the impact itself have to be considered. If the load combinations are created manually, make sure that the "Accidental design situation" is assigned to the corresponding load combinations (Image 06) and the correct load duration class, "Instantaneous" (Image 07).

Image 06 - General Data in TIMBER Pro with Assigning Design Situation

Image 07 - Assigning Load Duration

By this assignment, the accidental design situation in the ultimate limit state is considered with a partial safety factor of 1.0, as required in [6]. Moreover, in this case, the strength is multiplied by a kmod of 1.1 (Service Class 2) because of the instantaneous load duration. In this example, the column has a ratio of 0.47 ≤ 1.00 and the impact of the passenger car is thus designed. The design works even with a kmod value of 0.9 (Service Class 3).

Image 08 - Design Performed for Column Hit by Car

As already explained, it is worth taking a look at the complete failure of the column (Image 02). For this purpose, it is not necessary to consider failure or deletion of the member in a separate file. The column can be easily deactivated for specific load combinations. For the complete failure of the column, a new load combination will be created where only the self-weight is included and the column is deactivated in the calculation parameters.

Image 09 - Deactivating Column for Certain Load Combination

Since the structure is certainly supported immediately after the column fails, an "instantaneous" load duration can be applied for this load combination. The purlin design under self-weight for the accidental design situation amounts to 0.48 ≤ 1.00 (TIMBER Pro Case 3).

Image 10 - Purlin Design for Complete Column Failure

Designing Joints and Foundations

Furthermore, the fasteners must be checked in case of an impact. Therefore, it is necessary to verify that the column base and the connection of the column to the purlin above are dimensioned sufficiently. The type of the structure governs whether the impact load must be transferred into the foundation or not. In [5], NDP to 4.1 (1), Note 3, the transfer of forces generally does not govern for buildings. This statement is true for the carport mentioned in the example.

Author

Dipl.-Ing. (FH) Gerhard Rehm

Dipl.-Ing. (FH) Gerhard Rehm

Product Engineering & Customer Support

Mr. Rehm is responsible for the development of products for timber structures, and provides technical support for customers.

Keywords

Impact Impact load Carport Accidental action Vehicle Column impact

Reference

[1]   Eurocode 0: Basis of structural design: EN 1990:2002
[2]   Nationaler Anhang - National festgelegte Parameter - Eurocode 0: Grundlagen der Tragwerksplanung; DIN EN 1990/NA:2010-12
[3]   Eurocode 1: Actions on structures - Part 1-1: General actions - Densities, self-weight, imposed loads for buildings; EN 1991-1-1:2010-12
[4]   Eurocode 1: Einwirkungen auf Tragwerke - Teil 1-7: Allgemeine Einwirkungen - Außergewöhnliche Einwirkungen; DIN EN 1991-1-7:2010-12
[5]   Nationaler Anhang - National festgelegte Parameter - Eurocode 1: Einwirkungen auf Tragwerke - Teil 1-7: Allgemeine Einwirkungen - Außergewöhnliche Einwirkungen; DIN EN 1991-1-7/NA:2010-12
[6]   Eurocode 5: Design of timber structures - Part 1-1: General - Common rules and rules for buildings; EN 1995-1-1:2010-12

Downloads

Links

Write Comment...

Write Comment...

  • Views 20545x
  • Updated 11 January 2023

Contact Us

Contact Dlubal

Do you have any further questions or need advice? Contact us via phone, email, chat or forum or search the FAQ page, available 24/7.

+49 (0) 9673 9203-0

[email protected]

Online Training | English

Eurocode 5 | Timber Structures According to DIN EN 1995-1-1

Online Training 31 August 2023 8:30 AM - 12:30 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | University Days - Day 2 | USA

Online Training 16 August 2023 12:00 PM - 2:00 PM EDT

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | University Days - Day 1 | USA

Online Training 15 August 2023 12:00 PM - 2:00 PM EDT

Member and Surface Design of Timber Components in RFEM 6

Member and Surface Design of Timber Components in RFEM 6

Webinar 20 July 2023 2:00 PM - 3:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

Eurocode 5 | Timber Structures According to DIN EN 1995-1-1

Online Training 22 June 2023 8:30 AM - 12:30 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Students | Introduction to Timber Design

Online Training 24 May 2023 4:00 PM - 5:00 PM CEST

2018 NDS CLT Design in RFEM 6

2018 NDS CLT Design in RFEM 6 (USA)

Webinar 2 May 2023 2:00 PM - 3:00 PM EDT

Online Training | English

Eurocode 5 | Timber Structures According to DIN EN 1995-1-1

Online Training 16 March 2023 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM CET

Modeling and Design of CLT Panels in RFEM 6

Modeling and Design of CLT Panels in RFEM 6

Webinar 19 January 2023 2:00 PM - 3:00 PM CET

Online Training | English

Eurocode 5 | Timber Structures According to DIN EN 1995-1-1

Online Training 8 December 2022 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM CET

RFEM 5
RFEM

Main Program

Structural engineering software for finite element analysis (FEA) of planar and spatial structural systems consisting of plates, walls, shells, members (beams), solids, and contact elements

Price of First License
4,350.00 EUR
RSTAB 8
Structural Frame Analysis Software RSTAB

Main Program

Structural engineering software for designing frame, beam, and truss structures, as well as performing linear and nonlinear calculations of internal forces, deformations, and support reactions

Price of First License
2,850.00 EUR
RFEM 5
RF-TIMBER Pro

Add-on Module

Timber design according to Eurocode 5, SIA 265, and/or DIN 1052

Price of First License
1,450.00 EUR
RSTAB 8
TIMBER Pro

Add-on Module

Timber design according to Eurocode 5, SIA 265 and/or DIN 1052

Price of First License
1,250.00 EUR