Model in RFEM
By describing the stability analysis of a slender, restrained column, we look at the differences of both approaches regarding the nonlinear calculation according to EN 1992-1-1, 5.7 and 5.8.6.
This model is presented as example 1 in [14].
The loading corresponds to the specifications from [14]. In load case 1, the design value NEd = 1059.5 kN is taken into account.
As shown in the figure above, the loading is entered eccentrically. The eccentricity can be determined geometrically or with an additional moment MSd = 1059.5 ⋅ 0.05 = 52.98 kNm. In our example, the load is introduced eccentrically through a short member.
The inclination of the column is considered as an imperfection in load case 2. The value of the inclination is calculated as 1/φ = 1/0.003536 = 282.81.
The concrete's modulus of elasticity is defined with 26230 N/mm2 according to the specification in [14].
For analyzing the load-deformation behavior, we define the following load combinations:
- Design-relevant combination:
CO 1 |
LC1 + LC2 |
- Alternatives:
CO 2 |
0.20 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 3 |
0.50 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 4 |
0.70 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 5 |
0.80 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 6 |
0.90 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 7 |
0.92 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 8 |
0.94 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 9 |
0.96 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 10 |
0.97 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 11 |
0.98 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 12 |
0.99 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 13 |
1.05 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
CO 14 |
1.10 ∙ LC1 + LC2 |
No stiffness reduction by the partial safety factor γM is carried out for the calculation (RFEM default setting).
The calculation with RFEM provides the following internal forces and deformations:
Load combination |
Axial force |
Moment |
Moment |
Column head displacement |
CO 1 |
−1059.50 |
82.59 |
170.58 |
82.71 |
CO 2 |
−211.90 |
|
18.55 |
9.27 |
CO 3 |
−529.75 |
|
56.18 |
27.77 |
CO 4 |
−741.65 |
|
91.27 |
44.77 |
CO 5 |
−847.60 |
|
113.28 |
55.36 |
CO 6 |
−953.55 |
|
139.33 |
67.83 |
CO 7 |
−974.74 |
|
145.12 |
70.59 |
CO 8 |
−995.93 |
|
151.12 |
73.45 |
CO 9 |
−1017.12 |
|
157.36 |
76.42 |
CO 10 |
−1027.71 |
|
160.57 |
77.95 |
CO 11 |
−1038.31 |
|
163.84 |
79.51 |
CO 12 |
−1048.91 |
|
167.18 |
81.09 |
CO 13 |
−1112.47 |
|
186.66 |
91.29 |
CO 14 |
−1165.45 |
|
208.71 |
100.80 |