1065x
002700
2019-03-27

Question

In my model, I obtain different results in comparison with a manual calculation and other software.
What could be the reason?


Answer:
By default, the shear stiffnesses of members are activated in the program (see Image 01). The method of analysis and the defined stiffness factors (see Image 02) also affect the calculation. However, the parameters mentioned above are often neglected in the manual calculation, which of course contributes to a result difference. If these functions are deactivated, the results are usually identical to the manual calculation.