FAQ 003045 EN

Helpful Questions & Answers

  • Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

My model is unstable. What could be the reason?

Answer

A calculation break‑off due to an unstable system can have different reasons. On one hand, it can indicate a "real" instability due to overloading the structural system; on the other hand, modeling inaccuracies may also be responsible for this error message. In the following text, you can find a possible procedure for finding the cause of the instability.

1. Modeling Check 

First, you should check if the modeling of the structural system is correct. We recommend using the model check tools provided by RFEM/RSTAB (Tools → Model Check). For example, these options allow you to find identical nodes and overlapping members, so you can delete them, if necessary.


Furthermore, you can calculate the structure subjected to pure dead load in a load case according to the linear static analysis, for example. If results are displayed subsequently, the structure regarding the modeling is stable. If this is not the case, the most common causes are listed below (see also the "Model Check" video under "Downloads"):

  • Incorrect Definition of Supports / Lack of Supports
    This can lead to instabilities, as the structure is not supported in all directions. Therefore, the support conditions must be in equilibrium with the structural system as well as with the external boundary conditions. Statically underdetermined systems can also lead to calculation aborts due to a lack of boundary conditions.



  • Torsion of Members About Their Own Axis
    If members rotate about their own axis - that is, a member is not supported about its own axis - this can lead to instabilities. This is often caused by the settings of member hinges. Thus, it may happen that the torsional releases are entered at both the start node and the end node. However, you should pay attention to the warning that appears when starting the calculation.



  • Missing Connection of Members
    In the case of large and complex models in particular, it may quickly happen that some members are not connected to each other, and thus they "float in the air". Also, if you forget about crossing members that should intersect with each other, this can lead to instabilities as well. A solution provides the model check of "Crossing Unconnected Members", which searches for members that cross each other, but do not have a common node at the intersection point.



  • No Common Node
    The nodes rest apparently at the same location, but on closer inspection, they deviate slightly from each other. This is often caused by CAD imports, and you can correct it using the model check.



  • Formation of Hinge Chain
    Too many member end hinges on a node can cause a hinge chain that leads to a calculation abort. For each node, only n‑1 hinges with the same degree of freedom relative to the global coordinate system may be defined, where "n" is the number of connected members. The same applies to line releases.



2. Check of Stiffening

If the stiffening is missing, it may also lead to calculation aborts due to instabilities. Therefore, you should always check whether the structure is stiffened sufficiently in all directions.


3. Numerical Problems

An example of this is shown in Image 08. It is a hinged frame that is stiffened by tension members. Because of the column contractions due to vertical loads, the tension members receive small compressive forces in the first calculation step. They are removed from the structure (since only tension can be absorbed). In the second calculation step, the model is unstable without these tension members. There are several ways to solve this problem. You can apply a prestress (member load) to the tension members in order to "eliminate" the small compressive forces, assign small stiffness to the members, or remove the members one by one in the calculation (see Image 08).


4. Detecting Causes of Instability


  • Automatic Model Check with Graphical Result Display
    The RF‑STABILITY (RFEM) add-on module can help you to obtain the graphical display of the instability cause. Select the "Calculate eigenvector for unstable model…" (see Image 09), and it is possible to calculate the unstable structure. The eigenvalue analysis is performed on the basis of the structural data so that the instability of the affected structural component is displayed graphically as a result.



  • Critical Load Problem
    Is it possible to calculate load cases or load combinations according to the first-order analysis and the calculation only increases from the second-order analysis onwards. Order, there is a stability problem (critical load factor less than 1.00). The critical load factor indicated which coefficient must be used to multiply the load so that the model subjected to a specific load becomes unstable (for example, buckling). It follows: A critical load factor smaller than 1.00 means that the structure is unstable. Only a positive critical load factor greater than 1.00 means that the load due to the predefined axial forces multiplied by this factor leads to the buckling failure of the stable structure. In order to find the "weak point," the following approach is recommended, which requires the RF‑STABILITY (RFEM) or RSBUCK (RSTAB) add-on module (see also the video "Critical Load Problem" under "Downloads").

    First, it is necessary to reduce the load of the affected load combination until the load combination becomes stable. The load factor in the calculation parameters of the load combination can help. This also corresponds to the manual determination of the critical load factor if the RF‑STABILITY or RSBUCK add-on module is not available. In the case of pure linear structural elements, it may already be sufficient to calculate the load combination according to the geometrically linear analysis and select this directly in the add-on module. Then, the buckling curve or shape can be calculated and displayed graphically on the basis of this load combination in the corresponding add-on module. The graphical result display allows you to find the "weak point" in the structure and then optimize it specifically. By default, the RF‑STABILITY or RSBUCK add-on modules only determine global mode shapes. In order to also determine the local mode shapes, it is necessary to activate the member division (RF‑STABILITY), or to increase the division for trusses to "2" at least (RSBUCK).





Keywords

Instability System unstable Structure unstable Singularity Instability cause

Downloads

Links

Write Comment...

Write Comment...

  • Views 14071x
  • Updated 26 May 2022

Contact Us

Contact Dlubal

Unable to find the answer to your question? Contact us via phone, email, chat or forum or send us your question directly through our online form.

Submit Individual Question

+49 9673 9203 0

[email protected]

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Basics

Online Training 29 July 2022 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Basics | USA

Online Training 11 August 2022 12:00 PM - 4:00 PM EDT

Online Training | English

Eurocode 3 | Steel Structures According to DIN EN 1993-1-1

Online Training 8 September 2022 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Basics

Online Training 7 October 2022 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

Eurocode 3 | Steel Structures According to DIN EN 1993-1-1

Online Training 17 November 2022 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM CET

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 for Students | USA

Online Training 8 June 2022 1:00 PM - 4:00 PM EDT

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Students | Introduction to Timber Design

Online Training 25 May 2022 4:00 PM - 5:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Students | Introduction to Reinforced Concrete Design

Online Training 19 May 2022 4:00 PM - 5:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Students | Introduction to Steel Design

Online Training 4 May 2022 4:00 PM - 5:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Basics

Online Training 29 April 2022 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Students | Introduction to FEM

Online Training 27 April 2022 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

Eurocode 3 | Steel Structures According to DIN EN 1993-1-1

Online Training 27 April 2022 8:30 AM - 12:30 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RSECTION | Students | Introduction to Strength of Materials

Online Training 21 April 2022 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM CEST

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Students | Introduction to Member Design

Online Training 14 April 2022 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM CEST

Stability and Torsional Warping Analysis in RFEM 6

Stability Analysis and Torsional Warping (7 DOF) in RFEM 6

Webinar 17 March 2022 2:00 PM - 3:00 PM CET

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Basics

Online Training 9 March 2022 12:00 PM - 4:00 PM EDT

Online Training | English

Eurocode 3 | Steel Structures According to DIN EN 1993-1-1

Online Training 10 February 2022 8:30 AM - 12:30 PM CET

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Basics

Online Training 14 January 2022 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM CET

Online Training | English

Eurocode 3 | Steel Structures According to DIN EN 1993-1-1

Online Training 9 December 2021 8:30 AM - 12:30 PM CET

Online Training | English

RFEM 6 | Basics

Online Training 19 November 2021 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM CET

RFEM 5
RFEM

Main Program

Structural engineering software for finite element analysis (FEA) of planar and spatial structural systems consisting of plates, walls, shells, members (beams), solids, and contact elements

Price of First License
3,540.00 USD
RSTAB 8
Structural Frame Analysis Software RSTAB

Main Program

Structural engineering software for designing frame, beam, and truss structures, as well as performing linear and nonlinear calculations of internal forces, deformations, and support reactions

Price of First License
2,550.00 USD