10177x
000982
2021-03-17

Unstable Model

The most common causes of unstable models are failing member nonlinearities such as tension members. As the simplest example, there is a frame with supports on the column footing and moment hinges on the column head. This unstable system is stabilized by a cross bracing of tension members. In the case of load combinations with horizontal loads, the system remains stable. However, if it is loaded vertically, both tension members fail and the system becomes unstable, which causes a calculation error. You can avoid such an error by selecting the exceptional handling of failing members under "Calculate" → "Calculation Parameters" → "Global Calculation Parameters".

Other causes of unstable models are failing supports or foundations. For example, the system of a building with support or foundation failure usually becomes unstable when calculating wind load cases. You can avoid this error by always calculating the individual load cases together with the self-weight in one CO, not separately.

Overly soft systems can also cause instability in a CO. If the load for the specified cross-section/surface thicknesses is so large that the program cannot find equilibrium in the deformed system, a calculation error occurs.

You can check this by setting the calculation type to "Geometrically linear static analysis" for the problematic CO under "Calculate" → "Calculation Parameters" → "Load Combinations" tab. The deformation according to the geometrically linear static analysis itself is usually too big, and the dimension of the elements has to be increased.

If instability occurs despite compliance with the points specified above, the cause is probably modeling errors. In this case, click "Tools" → "Model Check" and check if there are identical nodes, overlapping lines/members/surfaces, or crossing unconnected lines/members. In the case of imported systems in particular, it often happens that the elements are unconnected due to rounding differences. You should also check the boundary conditions such as hinges and supports.


Author

Mr. Fröhlich provides technical support to our customers and is responsible for development in the area of reinforced concrete structures.

Links