Shear Deformations of Framework Structures in Timber Construction

Technical Article on the Topic Structural Analysis Using Dlubal Software

  • Knowledge Base

Technical Article

In current literature, the formulas to determine internal forces and deformations manually are usually specified without considering the shear deformation. The deformations resulting from shear force are often underestimated in timber construction in particular.

Symbols used:
h ... cross-section height
L ... span
E ... modulus of elasticity
G ... shear modulus
κ ... shear correction factor
A ... cross-section area
w ... deformation

The low shear modulus respectively the low ratio of G/E govern here. This is given as 1/16 for softwood due to the anisotropy according to [1]. Isotropic materials provide a much larger ratio. For steel, for example, the result is a G/E ratio of 1/2.6.

Beam Theory

Whereas in the classical Bernoulli beam theory it is assumed that the cross-section of a member remains perpendicular to the member axis when deformed, the shear sliding is considered for the Timoshenko beam theory (flexible beam). As a result, the cross-section of a member no longer remains perpendicular to the member axis when deformed (see Figure 01). By assuming that the cross-section remains planar, it results in a uniform shear stress distribution along the beam height. However, since the distribution is parabolic, a shear correction factor is taken into account for the determination of shear areas. This is 5/6 for a rectangular cross-section. Thus, the shear stiffness of a rectangular member results in:

Formula 1

GA* = κ · G · A = 56 · G · A

Image 01 - Comparing the Deformations of the Bernoulli Beam and Timoshenko Beam

Standardization

The standard gives no indication as to whether the shear deformations for members have to be considered, or from which criterion. Therefore, the structural engineer has to make the decision.

Example:

A simple example will demonstrate the influence of shear deformations. We consider a pinned single-span beam designed as a downstand beam. The details are shown in Figure 02.

Image 02 - Single-Span Beam Example

First, we only want to determine the deformation from the moment's curvature. For the system shown, the characteristic deformation is:

Formula 2

wM = 5 · qz · L4384 · E · Iy = 3,09 mm

The component of the shear deformation can be derived, for example, with the working set or simplified from the investigations from [2] or [3]. For a pinned single-span beam, this results in:

Formula 3

wV = qz · L28 · κ · G · A = 1.03 mm

The total deformation is thus:

Formula 4

wtot = wM  wV = 3.09  1.03 = 4.12 mm 

In this example, the shear deformation ratio is already 25% of the total deformation. Figure 03 graphically shows the individual deformation components.

Image 03 - Superpositioning Deformation Components

Slenderness

The slenderness of a member is decisive for the shear deformation component. While shear deformations are negligible for slender members with a large L/h ratio, they have a significant influence on compact members with a small L/h ratio.

Figure 04 shows the influence of the shear deformation on the total deformation in a diagram. For hinged single-span beams with a rectangular cross-section, the shear deformation is predominant up to an L/h ratio of 4. Only then does the ratio predominate from the moment curvature. From an L/h ratio of 12, the influence of the shear deformation is only 10% of the total deformation.

Image 04 - Influence of Shear Deformation on the Total Deformation for Single-Span Beams with a Rectangular Cross-Section

Statically Indeterminate Systems

In statically indeterminate systems, shear deformation has a greater influence than in statically determined systems. In this case, the deformations due to shear force have an influence on the bending moment and thus also on the bending deformations. This redistribution may, for example, have a positive effect on supporting moments (see Figure 05).

Image 05 - Moment Redistribution Due to Shear Deformation

Shear Deformations in RFEM and RSTAB

The shear deformations for members are automatically taken into account in RFEM and RSTAB. For control calculations, however, they can also be neglected with the function shown in Figure 06. If the check box is selected, the shear deformations are considered. If it is deactivated, only the deformation components from the bending moment are considered.

Image 06 - Considering Shear Deformation in RFEM and RSTAB

Summary

In many practical situations, shear deformations can be neglected because they do not contribute significantly to the total deformation. For compact members, the shear deformation must not be neglected any longer. For RFEM and RSTAB, the shear deformation is always considered by default; for manual calculations, it is necessary to use tools (see [2] or [3]).

Author

Dipl.-Ing. (FH) Gerhard Rehm

Dipl.-Ing. (FH) Gerhard Rehm

Product Engineering & Customer Support

Mr. Rehm is responsible for the development of products for timber structures, and provides technical support for customers.

Keywords

Shear deformation Shear area Shear correction factor Bernoulli Timoshenko

Reference

[1]   Bauholz für tragende Zwecke - Festigkeitsklassen; EN 338:2016
[2]   Eierle, B.; Bös, B.: Schubverformungen von Stabtragwerken in der praktischen Anwendung, Bautechnik 90, Seiten 747 - 752. Berlin: Ernst & Sohn, 2013
[3]   Eierle, B.; Bös, B.: Schubverformungen von Holztragwerken, Bauen mit Holz 90, Seiten 33 - 38. Köln: Bruderverlag, 2015

Downloads

Links

Write Comment...

Write Comment...

  • Views 5753x
  • Updated 27 October 2021

Contact us

Contact Dlubal

Do you have questions or need advice?
Contact our free e-mail, chat, or forum support or find various suggested solutions and useful tips on our FAQ page.

+49 9673 9203 0

info@dlubal.com

RFEM 5
RFEM

Main Program

Structural engineering software for finite element analysis (FEA) of planar and spatial structural systems consisting of plates, walls, shells, members (beams), solids and contact elements

Price of First License
3,540.00 USD
RSTAB 8
Structural Frame Analysis Software RSTAB

Main Program

The structural engineering software for design of frame, beam and truss structures, performing linear and nonlinear calculations of internal forces, deformations, and support reactions

Price of First License
2,550.00 USD
RX-TIMBER 2
RX-TIMBER Glued-Laminated Beam

Stand-Alone Program

Timber design of single-span and wide-span glulam beams according to Eurocode 5 or DIN 1052

Price of First License
1,120.00 USD
RX-TIMBER 2
RX-TIMBER DLT

Stand-Alone Program

Timber design of simple, continuous and Gerber beams with or without cantilever according to Eurocode 5 or DIN 1052

Price of First License
360.00 USD