Analysis of Load-Bearing Capacity of Bolted Frame Joints According to EC 3-1-8

Technical Article

When designing bending-resistant connections from I-beams, the connection is dissolved into the individual parts. For these basic components of a joint, there are separate formula calculators for load-bearing capacity and stiffness. In RFEM and RSTAB, it is possible to design frame joints using the RF-/FRAME-JOINT Pro add-on module.

Figure 01 - Frame Joint in RF-/FRAME-JOINT Pro

The basic components of a rigid bolt connection are:

  • Column web field with shearing stress
  • Column web with transversal compression
  • Column web with transversal tension
  • Column flange with bending
  • End plate with bending stress
  • Girder or column flange and web with compressive stress
  • Girder web with tensile stress
  • Bolts with tensile stress
  • Bolts with shear stress
  • Welds
  • Tapers

While designs of the most basic components can be carried out relatively simply and quickly using the conventional formulas, the proof design of the end plate with bending stress as well as the column flange with bending is a time-consuming task. For these two components, an equivalent T-stub flange is used as the analytical model.

T-Stub Flange

A tee is cut out of the actual model. Bolt rows subjected to tensile stress are considered and evaluated once separately and once as a group. The governing load-bearing capacity is determined from the lowest resistance of the sum of the individual bolt rows or the group value. The bolts in the bending compression area are used for the shear force transmission. The bolt rows are combined in bolt groups, which lie within the flanges or stiffeners. For the design of the end plate with bending stress, the T-stub is created from the end plate with a girder web for the internal bolt rows; in the case of an overhanging end plate with the external bolt row, the T-stub of the end plate corresponds to the girder flange. In order to be able to also design the overhanging part of the end plate, this will be divided and mirrored to the equivalent T-stub flange.

Figure 02 - T-Stub End Plate

For the design of the column flange with bending, the T-stub is created from the column flange and the column web.

Figure 03 - T-Stub Column

The contact force Q, which may occur between the free edge and the bolt row, is applied as the resultant of the surface pressure in the contact gap at the boundary point of the stub flange. It is possible to achieve significantly higher load-bearing capacities with the contact forces. So when modelling a connection, it is thus reasonable to arrange the position of the bolts in such a way that a restraint can also occur. For example, the contact force can be enforced by arranging a larger spacing of the bolt row from the girder web.

Figure 04 - T-Stub Analytical Model

Failure Modes

Three failure modes are possible.

Mode 1: Pure Flange Yielding
In the case of a soft end plate, plastic hinges arise on the bolt axis and near the stub web without reaching the bolt breaking force. The load-bearing capacity of the equivalent T-stub flange can be calculated according to two different methods, provided that the contact forces can occur. RF-/FRAME-JOINT Pro applies Method 1.

Figure 05 - Failure Mode 1

If there are no contact forces resulted from the calculation, the load-bearing capacity is halved. The same failure mode then also arises in Mode 2.

Figure 06 - Failure in Mode 1 and 2 Without Contact Forces

Mode 2: Bolt Failure Concurrent with Flange Yielding
In the case of an optimum accordance between the end plate thickness and the bolt diameter, a plastic hinge arises near the T-stub web and the bolts fail.

Figure 07 - Failure Mode 2

Mode 3: Bolt Failure
In the case of a rigid end plate and undersized bolts, these fail with no plastic hinges arising. This failure mode should be avoided as far as possible since the connection becomes inefficient in this case.

Figure 08 - Failure Mode 3

Effective Lengths

The effective lengths are required for determining the plastic moment resistance of the T-stub and do not need necessarily match the actual lengths of the model.

By using the effective lengths on the equivalent T-stub, the spatial environment of the real connection is taken into account so you obtain the same load-bearing capacities of the design model and the actual model.

Figure 09 - Effective Length

Depending on the geometry and failure mode, the end plate may get a circular or a rectilinear yield line pattern which can have a great impact on the effective lengths of the T-stubs. In the case of the plastic failure of the end plate, a yield cone arises, which cannot be formed completely in Mode 2 and thus it takes a non-circular yield pattern.

Figure 10 - Yield Line Pattern

Determining Moment Resistance

The moment resistance of a connection is calculated from the sum of the determined tension resistance of each bolt row multiplied by the respective spacing to the compression point.

If the tension resistance resulting from the design of the bolt rows as a group is lower than the sum of the individual T-stub flanges, then the respective row may only apply the component that contributes to the total load-bearing capacity of the bolt group.

The central axis of the compression flange should be assumed as the compression point.

Figure 11 - Moment Resistance

Reference

[1] Eurocode 3: Design of steel structures - Part 1-8: Design of joints; EN 1993-1-8:2005 + AC:2009

Links

Contact us

Contact to Dlubal

Do you have any questions or need advice?
Contact us or find various suggested solutions and useful tips on our FAQ page.

+49 9673 9203 0

info@dlubal.com

RFEM Main Program
RFEM 5.xx

Main Program

Structural engineering software for finite element analysis (FEA) of planar and spatial structural systems consisting of plates, walls, shells, members (beams), solids and contact elements

RSTAB Main Program
RSTAB 8.xx

Main Program

The structural engineering software for design of frame, beam and truss structures, performing linear and nonlinear calculations of internal forces, deformations, and support reactions

RFEM Connections
RF-FRAME-JOINT Pro 5.xx

Add-on Module

Design of rigid bolted frame joints according to Eurocode 3 or DIN 18800

RSTAB Connections
FRAME-JOINT Pro 8.xx

Add-on Module

Design of rigid bolted frame joints according to Eurocode 3 or DIN 18800